Kamis, 17 September 2009

Screwing Daisy!!

CHAPTER I
INTRODUCTION


1.1. Background of the study

Literature is reflection of human’s life. And through literature, people can pour all the things inside the mind. Problem, love, distress, madness, memory, war, peace, even the wildest fantasy that people can make. They write, decorate, design, polish it to whatever shape in writing. And often the message and spirit of literature will be the stepping stone where readers would spring over the obstacles and turn their life to be the good beautifully ones.
Within the literature, lies the very basic of human wish, whatever it is. From individually wish and mass or public hope, this also showing how cripples and full disability or conflict that happen in human life.
Literature comes in the form of play, poetry and fiction. It is believed that each type of literature has its own characteristic as the superiority. However, a novel (fiction) has more significance compared to play or even poetry. Firstly, novel has wider range readers of the other literary genres because novel is a portrait of life, which can attract the readers with the truth of its characters and themes. Secondly, novel is much closer to the reality than the other genres. Then, since a novel is defined as an extended narrative covering a wide range of character and expression, thus both the writer and the reader may share experiences and the novel that uses both physical and psychological of the character in the story may add scene and feeling to the readers’ imagination.
A novel also can have various and different themes that will attract the readers to scrutinize, and one of the example is Daisy Miller. Daisy Miller wrote by Henry James as a reflection of cultural and social clash that happen between east and west, the gap of status in different community, between high class and lower class. A novella with the eponymous protagonist, the young and innocent American Daisy Miller, finds her values in conflict with European sophistication. Henry James himself was born in New York, United States of America, though he spent his life as an author in England. James is one of the key figures of 19th century literary realism (wikipedia.com). His masterpieces: The Portrait of a Lady (1881), in which once again a young American woman becomes a victim of her provincialism during her travels in Europe. The Bostonians (1886) is set in the era of the rising feminist movement. What Maisie Knew (1897) depicts a preadolescent girl, who must choose between her parents and a motherly old governess. In The Wings of the Dove (1902) an inheritance destroys the love of a young couple. James considered The Ambassadors (1903) his most "perfect" work of art. James's most famous short story is "The Turn of the Screw", a ghost story in which the question of childhood corruption obsesses a governess.
Henry James also an author of the numerous literary criticism: French Poets and Novelists (1878), Notes on Novelists (1914). And memoirs and autobiography such as The Middle Years (unfinished, published posthumously 1917), A Small Boy and Others (1913), Notes of a Son and Brother (1914). And play entitled Guy Domville (1895) and series of Theatrical (1913, 1914). Author like James insisted that writers in Great Britain and America should be allowed the greatest freedom possible in presenting their view of the world, as French authors were. His imaginative use of point of view, interior monologue and unreliable narrators in his own novels and tales brought a new depth and interest to realistic fiction, and foreshadowed the modernist work of the twentieth century (wikipedia.com). He died in February 28, 1916 in London, whilst the world still held up high the conflicts which he ever write in his works.
This research chooses Daisy Miller to be discussed rather than other works because the theme in Daisy Miller is more suitable for this discussion. The volume of social status value is obviously sharper.







1.2. Statement of the problems
According to the idea presented in the background of the study, the writer would like to formulate the problems as follows:
1. How is Daisy Miller social status described in Henry James’ Daisy Miller?
2. How the other characters response to Daisy Miller’s social status?

1.3. Objectives of the study
From the statement of the problems mentioned above, the objectives of the study are:
1. To understand Daisy Miller and other characters social status.
2. To reveal how the other characters response Daisy Miller

1.4. Significant of the study
The writer wishes and expects the research will give the contribution to the readers about how important the social status among European. Hopefully, by reading this thesis, the readers can change their paradigm into the better one after knowing the different social status within the community.

1.5. Scope and limitation of the study
The writer limits this study only to Daisy Miller, Winterbourne, Mrs. Costello and Mrs. Walker social status.


1.6. Research methods
1. The data: this analysis uses a library research and collects primary and additional data.
2. The main data is novella Daisy Miller, and the additional data is numerous sources of books and online articles to support the writer analysis.



CHAPTER II
THEORETICAL FRAME WORK

Social Status
Social status is the differentiation of prestige and difference among individuals and group in the society (Polak, 1982:165). Social status also has another meaning, honor or prestige attached to one’s position in the society. Social status is influenced by social position. As Warga states that positions and evaluation of how well a person does job combine to give a person status or standing in a group’s pecking order (1983:141).
Status is one of the dimensions in the social stratification so; it is human if somebody wants to be treated respectfully by others. Social stratification is as more complex interplay of three distinct dimensions. First is economic equality, which Weber termed Class position. Weber uses of the “Class” refer not to crude categories but to a continuum on which anyone can be ranked from high to low. A second continuum is status, which measured social prestige, and the third is the dimension of power (Soekanto, 1982:119). Meanwhile according to Soekanto (Sosiologi Suatu Pengantar, 1982:118-119) states that stratification that is based on this status hierarchy classifies the society into two groups: honored people and common people. The honored people frequently emphasize the importance of their own history as the basic reason why they deserve the special place in a society. For instance, a ‘blue-blood’ will always look honorable in his daily life and in some cases he will get reluctant to join or to be joined by the members of common people in order to maintain the status.
Also in social status, there are two kinds of status namely ascribed status and achieved status. The first is the status that the person gets since he is born. And achieved status is a status that the person gained by their own effort, or in other words, it is a social position that a person assumes voluntarily which reflects personal skills, abilities and efforts (Soekanto, 1982:234). To measure one’s social status can be viewed from some aspects, those are: wealth, power, honor and education. And by having those aspects make one has own lifestyle, and of course lifestyle determines status.
CHAPTER III
ANALYSIS

In this part, the life of Daisy Miller within the novella, especially the ones dealing with her social status will be discussed as the main subject. This discussion also discusses about the response of other characters toward her, from the beginning up to the ending of the story.

3.1. Daisy Miller’s social status
The section will concern to discuss about Daisy Miller, her social status and whole things that relates to her story including to her point of view toward European society.
Annie P. Miller is young American Girl, the typical of free, innocent and beautiful girl. She belongs to rich American family, though European nobility does not concern whether rich or not, she is a common people.
“My father ain’t in Europe; my father’s in a better place than Europe;” (p. 2)

She comes to tour over Europe with her mamma and her little brother Randolph, until she landed in Vevey, Switzerland. A place that will change her life forever. Place where she accidentally become acquainted with Winterbourne. Daisy stay in Vevey with her family in a hotel at Vevey. She recognizes that Vevey is too quiet for her. She cannot found any society like in America. She also incapable to understand the people of Vevey and their basic custom. The innocent girl soon led herself to open other people negative opinion and accusation about her.
“The only thing I don’t like,” she proceeded, “is the society. There isn’t any society; or, if there is, I don’t know where it keeps itself. Do you? I suppose there is some society somewhere, but I haven’t seen anything of it. (p. 4)

But it is her innocence and uncultivated behavior that soon give the way to her to get closer with her new friend, Winterbourne. Soon Winterbourne introduced her to his aunt, who belongs to the upper class, the honored old-lady named Mrs. Costello. Daisy is agreed to see her, in case she wants to know Mrs. Costello royal life, and furthermore she is pursuing the exclusive life, the life of European royal class.
She would be very exclusive. I like lady to be exclusive; I’m dying to be exclusive myself. Well, we are exclusive, mother and i. we don’t speak to everyone—or they don’t speak to us. (p. 7)

She found a great many pretext in the rugged embrasures of Chillon for asking Winterbourne sudden question about himself—his family, his previous history, his tastes, his habits, his intentions—and for supplying upon corresponding points in her own personality. Of her own tastes, habits, and intention Miss Miller was prepared to give the most definite, and indeed the most favorable account. (p. 11)

Daisy is obviously wants to be the part of the higher status in Europe, her father, Ezra Miller is a successful businessman in America, yet Daisy and her family has neither title nor heir of noble at all. She only a common American girl, with all of her lacks of nobility knowledge. She doesn’t knows what nobility means, and she just uncultivated.
She cared very little for feudal antiquities and that the dusky traditions of Chillon made but a slight impression upon her. (p. 10)

And after she spends a lot of times in Vevey, she goes to Rome with herfamily and a courier named Eugenio. Rome is totally different in Daisy’s thought. She soon gathers more friends and acquainted with Giovanelli, a good looking Italian.
“It’s on account of the society—the society’s splendid. She goes round everywhere, she has made a great number of acquaintances. Of course she goes around more than I do. I must say they have been very sociable; they have taken her right in. (p. 13)

The society’s extremely select. There all kinds—English, and Germans, and Italians. I think I like the English best.

But in Rome, her uncultivated demeanor also raises local turmoil. She behaves so freely, she breaks the informal norms (Lenski, 1991). It is also the reflection of her social status, since common people behave the way they are.
“I never heard anything so stiff! If this is improper, Mrs. Walker,” she pursued, “then I am all improper, and you must give me up.
(p. 16)

In fact, Daisy recognizes what she has done. She sure knows that she is going beyond Rome’s custom, yet she can not understand why she must change her real habits. She is so confident that she is doing all right with her own rules.
Daisy’s defiance came from the consciousness of innocence, or from her being, essentially, a young person of the reckless class. (p. 21)

“Of course I care to know!” Daisy exclaimed seriously. “But I don’t believe it. They are only pretending to be shocked. They don’t really care a straw what I do. Besides, I don’t go round so much.” (p. 21)

Though Daisy is dying to be exclusive, she can not manage the way to be that. Her failure is the deal that she gets as a common American people among than honored European society, among European custom. It is because her demeanor and status what makes can not accept her. Status is the important one because by having status, one will be appreciated by the society (Sukamto 1977:14).

3.2. Other characters social status and their response to Daisy Miller
The main discussion of this part is how the others characters see Daisy Miller and what are their judgments to Daisy Miller. The characters that the writer analyzes are Frederick Winterbourne, Mrs. Walker, and Mrs. Costello. These characters are belonging to the upper class; the honored people which living in noble lifestyle in Europe. Though one of them has different judgment about Daisy’s behavior and social status, the rest, still hold the royal rules which tied their nobility, things that makes them different from common people.

 Frederick Winterbourne
He lives in Geneva for a long time, though deep down, he still American. Within the novella, described that he belongs to the upper class gentleman, good looking from sole to crown. This because his aunt is kind of noble old-lady who lives in Vevey. But unlike his aunt, he has much of acquaintances of many kind of person, he also like any thing about America, including the girls.
He had afterward gone to college there—circumstances which had led to his forming a great many youthful friendships. Many of these and they were a source of great satisfaction to him. (p. 1)

“American girls are the best girls,’ he said cheerfully to his young companion. (p. 2)

But when Daisy comes to him, he rather shocked by the girl’s attitude and manner, he recognizes that only American can done like such. He knows that Daisy, despite she is rich, she only common person. Her status is lower than him. The only thing that greatly attracts Winterbourne is her appearance and innocent style.
Winterbourne was a man of imagination and, as our ancestors used to say, sensibility; as he looked at her dress and, on the great staircase, her little rapid, confiding step, he felt as if there were something romantic going forward. (p. 10)

Winterbourne had not seen for a long time anything prettier than his fair countrywoman’s various features—her complexion, her nose, her ears, her teeth. He had a great relish for feminine beauty; he was addicted to observing and analyzing it; and as a regards this young lady’s face he made several observations. (p. 3)

When he try to get closer with her by introducing her to his aunt. He revealed that his aunt dislikes her. He can’t take his aunt judgment because she knows that the problem is only about her innocence, and her habit that does not match with European custom. Winterbourne’s feeling grow toward Daisy, he seems very comfortable with her, although he cannot refuse the fear of Daisy’s reckless behavior.
He had assented to the idea that she was “common”; but was she so, after all, or was he simply getting used to her commonness? (p. 10)

He had been a little afraid that she would talk loud, laugh overmuch, and even, perhaps desire to move about the boat a great deal. (p. 10)

Simply, he gets along so well with Daisy Miller. He spends a big deal of time with her whilst in Vevey. Of course a man like Winterbourne knows how to enjoy the taste of place like Castle of Chillon. But Daisy Miller does not know what is the meaning of it, to enjoy the antiqueness of Castle de Chillon. It is only a dull and dusky place to her. He knows that she surely can not catch the style.
She cared very little for feudal antiquities and that the dusky traditions of Chillon made but a slight impression upon her. (p. 10)

At the end of January, he fulfills the promise he made before to visit Daisy in Rome. His aunt has arrived there before him, and it makes Winterbourne shocked when he knows that his aunt has done her observation of Daisy’s whole family. Furthermore, he reveals that lovely Daisy has another man to flirt around.
She has picked up half a dozen of the regular Roman fortune hunters, and she takes them about to people’s houses. When she comes to a party she brings with her a gentleman with a good deal of manner and a wonderful mustache.”(p. 26)

Daisy then becomes so cold to him, she quiet forgets about Winterbourne and Vevey. But Winterbourne is stubborn, he act like a gentleman and ready to follow Daisy everywhere, he seems a bit forget about his own social status, he bursts down to Rome to get closer with Daisy only, though there is another man named Giovanelli who accompany her every time
His own mission, to her sense, apparently, was to consign her to the hands of Mr. Giovanelli; but Winterbourne, at once annoyed and gratified, resolved that he would do no such thing. (p. 14).

He sure about his own judgment about Daisy, despite his aunt accusations to her. He does not care about Daisy’s background; her lower status does not make any obstacles to him to get Daisy. He feels the only right man for Daisy is him, though Daisy spends most of her time with Giovanelli.
Winterbourne felt a superior indignation at his own lovely countrywoman’s not knowing the difference between a spurious gentleman and a real one. (p. 15)

“You’re a very nice girl; but I wish you would flirt with me, and me only,” said Winterbourne. (p. 18)

“I am not so fortunate,” said Winterbourne, “as your companion.” (p. 21)

Daisy’s attitude can not break him, otherwise he trying to let Daisy know about European custom, people and norms that obviously unfit to her. He wants Daisy follows the European customs, so that the people in the society can accept her as the way she is.
I don’t see why I should change my habits for them. (p. 18)

“That Daisy and her mamma have not yet risen to that stage of—what shall I call it?—of culture at which the idea of catching a count or a marchese begins. I believe that they are intellectually incapable of that conception.” (p. 20)
From the second quotation above, he recognizes that society’s judgment is right about her, yet he feels that everyone are too mean to her. He also thinks that Daisy attitude is caused by her social status, she cannot reach to be one of the honored people. For Winterbourne, Daisy Miller is innocent; her wide open refusal toward society is the result of her innocence. He knows that she likes Giovanelli is because his handsome face not his status among society, she can only decides a man from his face, and Winterbourne surely knows about this. Winterbourne only regrets what Daisy has done with Giovanelli in Rome.
He could not deny to himself that she was going very far indeed.
(p. 20)

Daisy’s defiance came from the consciousness of innocence, or from her being, essentially, a young person of the reckless class. (p. 21)

Daisy’s feeling toward Winterbourne is still mystery that she carried away to her grave, though she denies that she engaged with Giovanelli. Winterbourne will never be with her. He fails to make Daisy understand and Daisy refuses to understand. There is another obstacle, their different social status, the honored person and common person. They will never be together even though Daisy is alive.

 Mrs. Costello
Winterbourne’s aunt, she lives in Vevey and very liable to get headache. This old-lady loves Winterbourne who attentively visits her in frequent time. She belongs to the upper class and wants Winterbourne acts like her.
She was greatly pleased with him, manifesting her approbation by initiating him into many of the secrets of that social sway which, as she gave him to understand, she exerted in the American capital. (p. 6)

A dozen of the American colonists in Rome came to talk with Mrs. Costello, who sat on the little portable stool at the base of one of the great pilasters. The vesper service was going forward in splendid chants and organ tones in the adjacent choir. (p. 20)

She is the first person who plainly denies Winterbourne’s relationship with Daisy Miller. She thinks that Daisy Miller is not proper girl for him, because Daisy comes from lower status, unlike her and Winterbourne.
Miss Daisy Miller’s place in the social scale was low (p. 6)
She quiet annoyed when Winterbourne likes her, though she can not refuse the reason that Daisy’s prettiness is beyond everything. She believes that Daisy Miller also unable to distinguish the perfect gentleman with the fake gentleman, because she is only common American girl and American means bad to her.
“They are very common,” Mrs. Costello declared. “They are the sort of Americans that one does one’s duty by not—not accepting.” (p. 6)

“Of course she’s pretty. But she is very common.” (p. 6)

“Very likely they have never seen a man with such good manners, such a fine clothes, so like a gentleman. He probably corresponds to the young lady’s idea of a count. (p. 6)

She thinks him the most elegant man in the world, the finest gentleman. She has never seen anything like him; he is better, even, than the courier. (p. 20)

Mrs. Costello feels that she needs to protect Winterbourne, who is like son to her, from Daisy Miller. In her thought Winterbourne is making a mistake when he gets along with Daisy. Later on, when she knows that the girl visits Chateau de Chillon alone with her lovely nephew, she is very mad, and relieves that her refusal of Daisy Miller, who wants to know her is right when Winterbourne trying to introduce her to Daisy. Mrs. Costello is honored old-lady who will get reluctant to get along and know the common people, in order to maintain her status and Winterbourne’s status. She declares that Winterbourne should stay away from the low-class girl.
But I really think that you had better not meddle with little American girls that are uncultivated, as you call them. You have lived too long out of your country. You will be sure to make some great mistake. You are too innocent. (p. 6)

“And that,” she exclaimed, “is the young person whom you wanted me to know!” (p.11)

In Rome she also follows Daisy’s news, she reminds Winterbourne of how bad is Daisy, and she knows how she quickly makes some acquaintances with men down in Rome. To her Daisy and her family who treat a courier like a gentleman are only dreadful common people.
She has picked up half a dozen of the regular Roman fortune hunters, and she takes them about to people’s houses. When she comes to the party she brings with her a gentleman with a good deal of manner and a wonderful mustache. (p. 12)

“They are very dreadful people.” (p. 12)

She recognizes that Daisy is going too far in Rome; she can not accept the girl. Daisy will never get along with European custom, furthermore Daisy has done many improper activities which breaks local norms and customs. Mrs. Costello has different social status from Daisy; she never wants a girl like Daisy Miller.

 Mrs. Walker
Mrs. Walker is an American lady who has live in Vevey for several years. In Rome she stayed in Via Gregoriana, and held a party in some evening when Daisy’s family is invited as guests along with Winterbourne. She rather like Winterbourne in her acceptance of Daisy as common people though Mrs. Walker is also has a distinct status in the society. When Daisy decides to leave party to walk to Garden of Pincio to meet Giovanelli, she trying to stop her. She feels that she has a responsibility toward Daisy as her guest, and since she knows that Pincio is not safe place for a walk at the moment.
“Alone, my dear—at this hour?” Mrs. Walker asked. The afternoon was drawing to a close—it was the hour for the throng of carriages and of contemplative pedestrians. “I don’t think it’s safe my dear,” said Mrs. Walker. (p. 14)

“My dear young friend,” said Mrs. Walker, taking her hand pleadingly, “don’t walk off to the Pincio at this hour to meet a beautiful Italian.” (p. 14)

She hardly can reduce her worry when Daisy asks Winterbourne as her companion. Later on, she catches Daisy Miller, Giovanelli and Winterbourne and asks them to end the evening walks. She needs to protect everyone status here because she is the host of the party. She does not want Winterbourne, Daisy and Giovanelly become negative news later. It is simply because Rome’s customs does not allow unmarried girl walking with two different men at the hour, and it is such improper thing that will stain Winterbourne’s status and for Daisy, it is the way to ruin her. Furthermore, she is very disappointed with Daisy’s mamma that let her daughter acts crazily; Mrs. Walker thinks that it is pitiful.
“It is really too dreadful,” she said. “That girl must not so this sort of thing. She must not walk here with you two men. Fifty people have noticed her.” (p. 15)

Mrs. Walker knows that Daisy does not know about local norms and custom since she is quiet innocent, she is only a brat who spread negative accusations. But she does not mind to warn Daisy that what Daisy has done is improper and people around will talk about her later, if Mrs. Walker does not swiftly save her.
“It may be enchanting, dear child, but it is not the custom here,” (p. 16)

“You are old enough to be more reasonable. You are old enough, dear Miss Miller, to be talked about.” (p. 16)

“Everything that is not done here. Flirting with any man she could pick up; sitting in corners with mysterious Italians; dancing all the evening with same partners; receiving visits at eleven o’clock at night. Her mother goes away when visitors come.” (p. 17)

And like Mrs. Costello, she can not let Winterbourne do flirt with Daisy Miller. Winterbourne’s relationship will be scandal to her and society, and she knows that Winterbourne’s feeling toward Daisy is hard to be bent.
Within the novella Mrs. Walker trying to reminds Daisy that she is going too far. She trespasses the local custom and make the society talks about her. When Daisy died, Daisy never regrets her defiance to the society. And Mrs. Walker is the one who feels regret.








CHAPTER IV
CONCLUSION


Daisy Miller’s character in the novella is only an actual reflection of clash which still happens in every part of the world. Comes from a simple idea and end up with tragic ending. A social status is one of distinct idea in Daisy Miller’s life, how she failed to maintain it, is the next complexity that Henry James gives the reader. Daisy pulls herself to the surface as a surface as a daughter of a man, who the paper writer categorize him as the man with achieved status. But, when time faces her to the different world she fails to manage herself. What Daisy failed to shows to the public is her honor and education. Other aspects like power and wealth are also maintained in improper way. One can not coarsely define her improper or wrong, since she has her own idealism, though in the other side she wishes and dying to be the part of honored people. She is the strongest character in the novella, and like Bram Stoker’s Count Dracula who died with his idealism and love for Mina, Daisy is died with defiance toward society and hope for Winterbourne.
Daisy also spreads the indirect influence toward other characters. Her fail to upraise the social status makes Frederick Winterbourne considering himself any longer. Winterbourne can not help himself falling in love with Daisy, who according to his aunt is dreadful and vulgar. It is such a disease which quickly spread and caused everyone unrest.
The paper writer feels there are no ‘right’ or ‘wrong’ in society, only the differences/ what is appropriate in one culture may inappropriate in another. Hopefully this paper will encourage people to find a middle ground.






THE STUDY OF SOCIAL STATUS
IN HENRY JAMES’ DAISY MILLER













Indra Kusuma
0 6 2 1 5 4 0 3 1


ENGLISH LITERATURE DEPARTMENT
LANGUAGE AND ART FACULTY
SURABAYA STATE OF UNIVERSITY
2009
REFERENCES


James, Henry. 1904. Daisy Miller. Hayton Barton Press.
Polak, Maijor. 1982. Sosiologi Suatu Pengantar. Jakarta: PT. Ichtiar Baru – Van Hoeve.
Soekanto, Soerjono. 1982. Sosiologi Suatu Pengantar. Jakarta: CV. Rajawali.
Sukamto, Suryono. 1977. Sosiologi, Suatu Pengantar. Surabaya: Universitas Kristen Petra.
Wagenknecht, Edward. 1984. The Tales of Henry James. New York: Frederick Ungar Publishing Co.
Warga, Richard G. 1983. Personal Awareness: a Psychology of Adjustment: 3rd Edition. Boston: Mifflin Co.
http://manybooks.net/
http://www.scribd.com/

Tidak ada komentar:

Yeah...yeah...me...

Foto saya
Surabaya, Jawa Timur, Indonesia
[madhouse treatment now]